Exploring package-vc-install

Posted on 2022-11-30  ·  3 min read  ·  emacs

The Emacs 29 release branch was just cut—and it’s chock full of new features! In this post, I want to talk about the new package-vc-install function, which allows one to install packages directly from their respective upstream source; for example, GitHub. It can be seen as a built-in alternative to things like quelpa or straight.el.

The story so far

I’ve been using quelpa and quelpa-use-package to install packages that are not on any popular archive straight from source. Especially the latter package resulted in an almost seemless integration with the rest of my configuration; for example:
(use-package math-delimiters
  :quelpa (math-delimiters :fetcher github :repo "oantolin/math-delimiters"))

Recently, Emacs added built-in capabilities for installing a package directly from its remote repository. Eager to shave yet another external package from my otherwise ever growing list, I took package-vc.el out for a spin: turns out, it almost perfectly covers the use-case for which I—and perhaps a few other people—used quelpa up until now!

The most user-facing of these new functions is package-vc-install, with signature
(package-vc-install PACKAGE &optional NAME REV BACKEND)

In the simplest case, it takes a URL pointing to some online source as its argument and installs the respective package from there, guessing the name from the URL. In case that doesn’t work—or one wants more control, like requiring a specific revision—there are some other optional arguments available, see the function’s documentation.

Customising package-vc-install

When a package is already installed, package-vc-install will ask the user to interactively confirm whether they really want to overwrite the existing directory. Naturally, this is not a good experience when trying to use this in a non-interactive fashion.

There are a few ways one could go about fixing this. One of these is even documented in the manual: customise package-vc-selected-packages and then call package-vc-install-selected-packages, which works much like package-install-selected-packages. However, this feels unergonomic to me—at least considering that I want to use package-vc-install as a (hopefully) drop-in replacement for use-package’s quelpa keyword. Plus, I’d rather have the information that package X is not installed from *elpa local to the use-package declaration of X itself.

So, let’s take the easy way out and write a small wrapper:
(cl-defun slot/vc-install (&key (fetcher "github") repo name rev backend)
  "Install a package from a remote if it's not already installed.
This is a thin wrapper around `package-vc-install' in order to
make non-interactive usage more ergonomic.  Takes the following
named arguments:

- FETCHER the remote where to get the package (e.g., \"gitlab\").
  If omitted, this defaults to \"github\".

- REPO should be the name of the repository (e.g.,

- NAME, REV, and BACKEND are as in `package-vc-install' (which
  (let* ((url (format "https://www.%s.com/%s" fetcher repo))
         (iname (when name (intern name)))
         (pac-name (or iname (intern (file-name-base repo)))))
    (unless (package-installed-p pac-name)
      (package-vc-install url iname rev backend))))

This function can now be used under the init keyword of the use-package macro, almost without changing the shape of the declaration from above:
;; Before
(use-package math-delimiters
  :quelpa (math-delimiters :fetcher github :repo "oantolin/math-delimiters"))

;; After
(use-package math-delimiters
  :init (slot/vc-install :fetcher "github" :repo "oantolin/math-delimiters")
  ;; OR (slot/vc-install :repo "oantolin/math-delimiters")

In case you think I cherry picked the example, here is the full commit that exchanges quelpa for slot/vc-install.

That’s all folks!

Admittedly, my use of quelpa was rather primitive. I can imagine users more heavily invested in, for example, the straight.el ecosystem probably want a bit more out of their package manager than package.el can give them right now, even with the added convenience of package-vc.el. However, for me—and probably at least a few people out there—this is quite enough. After all, for anything more there’s always nix :)